Renewal by Andersen, a prominent window replacement company, generates significant customer discussion. Window installation, as a home improvement project, represents a considerable investment for homeowners seeking energy efficiency and aesthetic upgrades. Consequently, the Better Business Bureau (BBB) records many customer experiences, both positive and negative, relating to window replacement projects. Understanding customer financing options becomes a crucial aspect of evaluating the overall value proposition of the home renovation, specifically about renewal by andersen.

Image taken from the YouTube channel Carpenter’s Touch , from the video titled Renewal by Andersen VS Andersen Windows .
Unpacking the Value Proposition: About Renewal by Andersen Windows
This article aims to provide a balanced and informative review of Renewal by Andersen windows, tackling the central question: Is the cost justified? We will explore various aspects of the company, its products, installation process, customer experiences (both positive and negative), and ultimately help readers make an informed decision.
Understanding Renewal by Andersen: A Company Overview
Renewal by Andersen is the window replacement division of Andersen Corporation, a well-established and respected window and door manufacturer. Unlike many window companies, Renewal by Andersen handles the entire process, from initial consultation and custom manufacturing to installation and warranty servicing.
The Renewal by Andersen Business Model:
- Vertical Integration: Renewal by Andersen controls almost every aspect of the window replacement process. This includes design, manufacturing (using their Fibrex material), sales, installation, and service.
- Custom-Made Windows: Windows are specifically manufactured to fit the existing opening, reducing the need for extensive modifications to the home’s structure.
- Direct Sales: Renewal by Andersen primarily sells its products directly to homeowners through in-home consultations, rather than relying on third-party retailers.
- Limited Availability: While Andersen Corporation windows are widely available, Renewal by Andersen operates through a network of authorized locations, which means service isn’t universally accessible.
Examining the Fibrex Material: A Key Differentiator
Fibrex is a composite material proprietary to Renewal by Andersen, and a central selling point. Understanding its properties is crucial to evaluating the value proposition.
What is Fibrex?
- A blend of wood fiber and thermoplastic polymer.
- Claimed to offer the strength and stability of wood with the low-maintenance qualities of vinyl.
- Designed to resist rot, decay, and fungal growth.
- Offered in a range of colors and finishes.
Fibrex Advantages:
- Durability: Resistant to warping, cracking, and fading.
- Energy Efficiency: Offers good insulation properties, contributing to lower energy bills.
- Low Maintenance: Does not require painting or staining.
- Environmentally Friendly: Made with a portion of reclaimed wood fiber.
Fibrex Considerations:
- Cost: Fibrex windows are generally more expensive than vinyl windows.
- Repair Limitations: While durable, repairs can be more complex than with wood or vinyl.
- Aesthetic Limitations: The appearance might not appeal to everyone compared to traditional wood windows.
Delving into the Cost Factor: What Drives the Price?
Renewal by Andersen windows are generally positioned as a premium product, which translates to a higher price point. Understanding the contributing factors helps assess whether the cost aligns with the perceived value.
Factors Influencing Renewal by Andersen Pricing:
- Fibrex Material: The proprietary material itself contributes to the higher cost.
- Custom Manufacturing: Each window is custom-made, adding to the labor and material costs.
- Professional Installation: Installation is included in the price, and Renewal by Andersen uses its own certified installers.
- Warranty: Renewal by Andersen offers a comprehensive warranty, adding to the overall cost but providing peace of mind.
- Direct Sales Model: The direct sales approach involves commissions and overhead associated with in-home consultations.
Comparing Costs to Alternatives:
The following table provides a general comparison of Renewal by Andersen windows compared to other common window materials:
Material | Cost (per window, installed) | Pros | Cons |
---|---|---|---|
Vinyl | \$300 – \$800 | Affordable, low-maintenance, energy-efficient | Can look less aesthetically pleasing, less durable than other options |
Wood | \$500 – \$1,200 | Beautiful, natural appearance, strong and durable | Requires regular maintenance, susceptible to rot and insect damage |
Aluminum | \$400 – \$900 | Lightweight, durable, rust-resistant | Poor insulation, can be noisy |
Renewal by Andersen | \$800 – \$1,800 | Durable, energy-efficient, low-maintenance, comprehensive warranty | Higher initial cost, limited availability |
Note: These are average price ranges and can vary based on location, window size, and other factors.
Analyzing Customer Reviews: The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly
Customer experiences provide valuable insights into the real-world performance of Renewal by Andersen products and services. A thorough analysis of reviews across various platforms is essential.
Common Positive Feedback:
- Installation Quality: Many customers praise the professionalism and thoroughness of the installation teams.
- Window Performance: Customers often report improved energy efficiency and reduced noise levels.
- Warranty Support: Positive experiences are often associated with prompt and helpful warranty service.
- Aesthetics: Some customers appreciate the appearance and customization options offered by Renewal by Andersen.
Common Negative Feedback:
- High Price: The most frequent complaint revolves around the high cost of the windows.
- Sales Tactics: Some customers report feeling pressured during the sales process.
- Installation Issues: While many praise installation, some report problems or delays.
- Customer Service Challenges: Negative reviews sometimes highlight difficulties resolving issues or obtaining warranty service.
Where to Find Customer Reviews:
- Better Business Bureau (BBB): Provides ratings and reviews, as well as information on complaints.
- Consumer Affairs: Features verified customer reviews and ratings.
- Yelp: Offers local business reviews, including Renewal by Andersen locations.
- Online Forums and Social Media: Provides a platform for customers to share their experiences and ask questions.
Evaluating the Warranty: Protection and Peace of Mind
Renewal by Andersen offers a comprehensive warranty. Understanding the terms and conditions is crucial.
Key Warranty Components:
- Glass Warranty: Covers defects in the glass, including seal failure.
- Fibrex Material Warranty: Protects against defects in the Fibrex material.
- Installation Warranty: Covers issues related to the installation of the windows.
- Transferability: Some aspects of the warranty may be transferable to a new homeowner.
Important Warranty Considerations:
- Read the Fine Print: Carefully review the warranty document to understand the specific terms and conditions.
- Registration: Make sure to register the warranty after installation.
- Proper Maintenance: Follow recommended maintenance guidelines to avoid voiding the warranty.
Conclusion (Omitted as per instructions)
Renewal by Andersen: FAQs
Here are some frequently asked questions about Renewal by Andersen based on our review. We hope these help clarify any confusion and provide further insights.
Are Renewal by Andersen windows really worth the higher price?
Renewal by Andersen windows often come with a premium price tag. Whether they are "worth it" depends on your individual budget, needs, and priorities. Consider factors like energy efficiency savings, long-term durability, and aesthetic value against the initial investment. Our review highlights both pros and cons to help you make an informed decision.
What’s so "shocking" about the Renewal by Andersen review?
The "shocking" aspect refers to the unexpectedly high prices quoted for Renewal by Andersen windows compared to alternative replacement window options. While the quality is generally good, the price difference can be significant, leading some customers to experience sticker shock. It’s essential to get multiple quotes and compare offerings.
What are the alternatives to Renewal by Andersen if the price is too high?
Several excellent replacement window companies offer comparable or even superior products at more competitive prices. Explore local contractors and national brands that specialize in window replacement. Don’t hesitate to ask for referrals and read independent reviews to assess quality and reliability. When deciding about Renewal by Andersen, consider regional companies.
Does Renewal by Andersen offer any financing options?
Yes, Renewal by Andersen typically offers financing options to help customers manage the cost of their window replacement projects. However, it’s crucial to carefully review the terms and conditions of these financing plans, including interest rates and repayment schedules, before committing. Compare those terms against other possible financing alternatives for your new windows.
So, what do you think? Weighing the pros and cons when considering about renewal by andersen is key. Hopefully, this review gives you a better idea of whether they’re the right fit for your home!